Best Home Gym System, Peloton vs NordicTrack: What to Buy Used in 2026

If you're trying to pick the best home gym system, Peloton vs NordicTrack is the comparison most people land on, and buying used changes the answer. You're not just choosing a bike. You're choosing a platform: one membership, one app, and a set of machines that work together as you add to them over the years.

I help people buy and sell used fitness equipment for a living, and both brands come through our platform constantly. This guide covers how each system is built, what each one costs used based on real listings, which models I'd look for, the common problems and red flags on each side, and which system fits which kind of buyer.

Peloton vs NordicTrack: What a Home Gym System Actually Means

A home gym system is a set of machines that share one app and one membership. Peloton machines run the Peloton app. NordicTrack machines run iFIT. Once you buy into one, every machine you add later makes the most sense on the same platform.

Here's how the two lineups compare:

• Peloton: Bike, Bike+, Tread, Tread+, and Row. Strength training happens through app classes with your own dumbbells, so there's no Peloton cable machine to buy.
• NordicTrack: studio bikes (S15i, S22i), treadmills (Commercial 1750, 2450), incline trainers (X22i), rowers (RW900), and strength machines like the Fusion CST and the Vault mirror.

The core difference: Peloton has fewer machines, all built around the classes. NordicTrack has a much wider catalog with more hardware features, like decline on its bikes and steep incline on the X22i, plus its own strength machines.

How the Memberships Work When You Buy Used

This is the part most used buyers miss, and it's where the two systems differ the most.

Peloton: one All-Access membership covers every Peloton machine in your home, with separate profiles for everyone in the household. Buying used, you'll also pay Peloton's one-time used equipment activation fee (it was $95 when Peloton introduced it in 2024). Check the current amount before you budget. The seller has to remove the machine from their account first, so confirm that before pickup.

NordicTrack: the touchscreen classes and auto-adjusting incline and resistance run on an iFIT membership. iFIT offers individual and family plans. Before you buy a second NordicTrack machine, confirm with iFIT how your plan covers multiple machines. Without a membership, most iFIT machines still work for manual workouts, but you lose the features you're paying extra for.

The bottom line: if you plan to own three machines, run the membership math for your household before you pick a side. It's a monthly cost that outlasts the hardware purchase.

What Each System Costs Used

Here's what real listings on our platform look like for the core machines. These are the middle-of-the-market asking prices, not the outliers.

Role in the system	Peloton	Typical used price	NordicTrack	Typical used price
Bike	Bike	$650 to $1,050	S22i	$920 to $1,350
Premium bike	Bike+	$850 to $1,400	S22i (same, with decline)	$920 to $1,350
Treadmill	Tread	$1,650 to $2,450	Commercial 1750	$910 to $1,830
Premium treadmill	Tread+	$2,100 to $3,075	Commercial 2450	$1,500 to $2,475
Incline trainer	None	n/a	X22i	$1,680 to $2,275
Rower	Row	$1,650 to $2,450	RW900	$1,100 to $1,775
Strength	Dumbbells plus app	Varies	Fusion CST	$825 to $1,400

Two patterns stand out. Peloton's original Bike is the cheapest way into either system, with a median near $855 on our listings. And past the bike, NordicTrack hardware usually costs less used than the Peloton equivalent, most clearly on treadmills and rowers.

Add up median prices and a ride-and-run system comes to about $2,900 for a Peloton Bike plus Tread, and about $2,650 for an S22i plus a Commercial 1750. That gap is modest with two machines, and it grows when you add a rower or step up to a premium treadmill.

Which Models to Look For in Each System

On the Peloton side, I'd build around these:

• Bike or Bike+. The original Bike is the value pick. The Bike+ adds a rotating screen for floor workouts and auto-follow resistance, which is worth paying for if you'll use the screen off the bike.
• Tread. The slatted-belt Tread is the one most buyers want. The Tread+ is a bigger, pricier machine, and it's only worth it if you have the space and the budget.
• Row. Good if your household already lives in the Peloton app. Otherwise it's an expensive rower.

On the NordicTrack side:

• S22i. The studio bike most of our NordicTrack bike buyers end up with. Big screen, incline and decline, and it typically lists close to a used Bike+.
• Commercial 1750 or 2450. Full-size running treadmills that cost less used than a Peloton Tread.
• X22i. The incline walking machine. If walking uphill is your main workout, nothing in the Peloton lineup does what it does. Our S22i vs X22i comparison goes deeper on those two.
• Fusion CST. A hybrid cable strength trainer, and the main reason to pick NordicTrack if strength matters to you. See our Fusion CST review.

If you're only buying a bike and nothing else, our NordicTrack vs Peloton buying guide compares the bikes head to head.

Common Problems and Red Flags on Used Peloton and NordicTrack Machines

Every used connected machine shares the same first check: the screen. Power it on, log in, and start a class. A dead or glitchy touchscreen is the most expensive single failure on either brand.

Peloton red flags:

• Recall repairs not done. Peloton recalled seat posts on the original Bike in 2023 and the Tread's touchscreen mount in 2021, both with free fixes. Ask the seller whether the fix was done, and check the serial number against Peloton's recall pages.
• Account not released. If the seller hasn't removed the machine from their account, activation turns into a headache.
• Bike resistance knob and brake. Turn it through the full range. It should change smoothly, and pressing down should stop the flywheel.
• Tread slats. Walk the full belt and look for loose, cracked, or noisy slats.

NordicTrack red flags:

• Incline and decline motors. Run the full range on any S22i, X22i, or treadmill. Grinding, hesitation, or a machine that won't level out means an expensive repair.
• Belt and deck wear on treadmills. Look for a glazed belt, frayed edges, or a belt that slips under load.
• Console and iFIT login. Make sure the screen boots, connects to Wi-Fi, and can sign into an iFIT account.
• Machine weight and access. The X22i and Commercial treadmills are very heavy. Know your stairs and doorways before you commit.

When our drivers pick up a machine, they run a 30 to 50 point inspection and send the buyer photos and a video of it working before delivery. One buyer had a Peloton Tread delivered, and Norman, one of our delivery techs, had it set up and working in 45 minutes.

Strength Training: Where the Two Systems Split

This is the deciding factor for a lot of buyers. Peloton strength is app classes and your own dumbbells. That's cheap and flexible, but there's no Peloton machine adding resistance for you.

NordicTrack sells strength hardware inside the same iFIT system. The Fusion CST is a cable trainer with a digital resistance system, and the few listings I've seen run $825 to $1,400. That's a real advantage if you want cardio and cable strength on one membership.

If you're set on Peloton for cardio but want serious strength, the usual move is to pair it with a separate strength machine and accept a second app. That's a fine setup. Just count the second membership in your monthly cost.

Which Home Gym System Should You Buy Used?

1. You mostly ride, and classes keep you going: Peloton. Start with an original Bike, the cheapest entry into either system.
2. You want ride, run, and row on a tighter budget: NordicTrack. The savings on the treadmill and rower add up across a full system.
3. Incline walking is your main workout: NordicTrack X22i. Nothing in Peloton's lineup matches it.
4. You want cardio and cable strength on one membership: NordicTrack, built around a Fusion CST.
5. Several people in the house will use several machines: run both membership costs for your household first, then decide.

Whichever side you pick, buy the first machine, use it for a month, and only then add the second. Plenty of people buy a whole system and end up using one machine.

Peloton vs NordicTrack Home Gym System FAQ

Is Peloton or NordicTrack better for a full home gym?

NordicTrack offers more machine types, including strength equipment, and usually costs less used past the bike. Peloton is simpler and class-focused, with the cheapest entry point in its original Bike.

Do you need a membership to use a used Peloton or NordicTrack?

For the classes and connected features, yes. Peloton needs an All-Access membership plus a one-time used equipment activation fee. NordicTrack needs iFIT. Both machines can still do basic manual workouts without one.

Can one membership cover multiple machines?

Peloton's All-Access membership covers every Peloton machine in the home. For NordicTrack, check with iFIT how your plan covers multiple machines before you buy a second one.

What breaks most on used Peloton and NordicTrack machines?

Touchscreens on both. Beyond that, incline motors and treadmill belts on NordicTrack, and Tread slats and unrepaired recall items on Peloton.

How much does a used Peloton or NordicTrack home gym cost?

A single bike runs about $650 to $1,350 on our listings. At median prices, a bike and treadmill system comes to about $2,650 for NordicTrack and about $2,900 for Peloton.

Ready to build yours? Browse used Peloton equipment or used NordicTrack machines. Every machine is inspected at pickup, delivered into the room you want it in, and you get to test it before you pay.

Already have a machine you've outgrown? List it on Commonplace and our drivers handle the pickup. You get paid when it's loaded.