Gas vs Electric Golf Carts: Which Should You Buy Used?
If you have been scrolling listings for used gas golf carts for sale and second-guessing whether electric is the smarter buy, you are asking the right question at the right time. A used gas cart typically runs $4,000 to $8,000 depending on year and condition, while a comparable used electric cart lands in a similar range until you factor in the battery, which can add $900 to $2,000 the day it needs replacing. The gas-versus-electric choice is really a choice about how you plan to use the cart, where you live, and how much maintenance you actually want to do.
I help people buy and sell big, awkward, expensive stuff for a living. Golf carts are one of the most misunderstood things I see change hands, because most buyers fixate on the sticker price and ignore the running costs, the terrain, and what the thing will be worth in five years. This guide breaks down gas versus electric on the four things that actually decide the winner: cost to run and maintain, range and power, noise and hills, and resale value.
Used gas golf carts vs electric: the short answer
Buy gas if you drive long distances, tow, climb steep hills, or hate the idea of managing a battery. Buy electric if you mostly do short trips, want near-silent operation, and prefer plugging in over pumping gas. That is the whole decision in two sentences, and for most people the tie-breaker is terrain and trip length.
Here is the honest version. Gas carts are simpler to live with if you cover real miles, because refueling takes 90 seconds and you are back out. Electric carts are cheaper and quieter for short daily loops around a neighborhood or campground, but the battery is the whole ballgame. Get the battery wrong on a used electric cart and you have bought a very expensive lawn ornament.
Cost to run and maintain each
Electric carts are cheaper to run, gas carts are cheaper to fix. A lead-acid electric cart costs roughly $0.02 to $0.05 per mile in electricity. A gas cart burns closer to $0.10 to $0.20 per mile depending on fuel prices and how hard you drive it. Over a year of light neighborhood use, that difference is real but small, often under $200.
Maintenance is where the story flips. A gas cart has an engine, oil, a fuel filter, spark plugs, and a belt. None of that is expensive, and any small-engine shop can handle it. A gas cart that gets an oil change once a year will run for 20-plus years. Electric carts have almost no routine maintenance, which sounds like a win, right up until the battery pack dies.
Batteries are the hidden cost of buying used electric. A set of six lead-acid batteries costs $900 to $1,400 installed and lasts four to six years. Lithium packs cost $2,000 to $3,500 but last 8 to 10 years and weigh far less. When you look at used gas golf carts for sale versus used electric, always ask the seller the age of the battery pack. If it is over four years old on a lead-acid cart, mentally add a grand to the price.
Range and battery life on electric carts
A healthy electric cart goes 25 to 40 miles on a charge. Lithium carts push 40 to 60 miles. That is plenty for a golf course, a neighborhood, or a campground loop. The problem is that used electric carts rarely have a healthy pack. Range drops as batteries age, and a five-year-old lead-acid cart might only manage 10 to 15 miles before it is crawling.
Gas carts do not have this anxiety. A full tank goes 100 to 180 miles, and refilling is instant. If you live somewhere with long distances between stops, or you want to load up the family and go, gas removes the range math entirely. You never plan your day around a charge level.
Test the range before you buy any used electric cart. Take it up to full charge, drive it hard for a few miles, and watch how fast the charge meter drops. A quick drop under load is the tell that the pack is on its way out. This is exactly the kind of check that is hard to do when you are meeting a stranger in a parking lot, which is one reason I push people toward a real inspection instead of a handshake deal.
Noise, power, and hills
Gas carts are more powerful, electric carts are quieter. A gas engine produces more torque, so it climbs steep hills and hauls heavy loads without straining. If you live on a hilly property, tow a small trailer, or regularly carry four adults plus gear, gas is the safer bet. It will not bog down.
Electric carts are near silent, which is a genuine pleasure. No engine drone, no exhaust, no vibration. On flat ground with one or two people, a good electric cart feels smooth and quick off the line because electric motors deliver torque instantly. The trade-off shows up on hills and under heavy loads, where a stock electric cart can slow noticeably and drain the battery faster.
Think about where you actually drive. Flat neighborhood or campground? Electric is a delight. Hilly acreage, a farm, or a job site? Gas will not leave you stuck halfway up an incline with a dying battery.
Resale value difference
Gas carts hold value more predictably because there is no battery clock ticking. A well-kept gas cart depreciates slowly and sells easily, since the buyer is not inheriting a maintenance time bomb. Electric carts can hold value well too, but only if the battery is fresh. A used electric cart with an aging pack is a hard sell, because every smart buyer knows they are about to spend four figures on batteries.
Lithium changed this a little. A lithium-converted or lithium-native electric cart holds value strongly because the pack lasts a decade and buyers know it. If you are buying electric with resale in mind, lithium is worth the premium. If you are buying lead-acid electric, buy it cheap and expect to eat the battery cost eventually. For a deeper look at pricing across brands and battery types, see our guide on what a used golf cart actually costs.
Gas vs electric golf carts: side-by-side
| Factor | Used gas cart | Used electric cart |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to run | $0.10 to $0.20 per mile | $0.02 to $0.05 per mile |
| Routine maintenance | Oil, plugs, belt, filter | Almost none until battery |
| Big future cost | Rare engine repair | Battery pack: $900 to $3,500 |
| Range per fill/charge | 100 to 180 miles | 25 to 60 miles |
| Refuel/recharge time | 90 seconds | 4 to 8 hours |
| Noise | Engine drone | Near silent |
| Hills and towing | Strong | Weaker, drains battery |
| Resale predictability | High | High only with fresh battery |
What to check before you buy a used cart
Whether you land on gas or electric, the same inspection discipline protects you. A used cart is a used vehicle, and the difference between a good buy and a money pit is 20 minutes of checking. Here is the order I would run through:
- Battery age and voltage (electric) or engine start and idle (gas). This is the single biggest cost driver. Get it in writing.
- Range or fuel test. Drive it. Watch the charge meter or listen to the engine under load.
- Tires and brakes. Cracked tires and soft brakes are cheap tells that the cart sat or was neglected.
- Charger and cables (electric). A missing or off-brand charger is a red flag and a hidden $300 cost.
- Frame and floor rust. Especially on carts from coastal or salted-road areas.
- Title and paperwork. Street-legal carts need documentation. Confirm what you are getting.
- Seat, canopy, and lights. Small stuff, but it tells you how the cart was cared for.
If you want the full pre-purchase walkthrough, our guide to buying a used golf cart covers each check in detail. And if you are weighing a golf cart against other used outdoor vehicles, our pieces on what an RV is worth and used motorcycle value use the same resale logic.
How buying a used cart works without the parking-lot risk
The hardest part of buying a used golf cart is not choosing gas or electric. It is trusting a stranger, moving a 900-pound machine, and paying before you know the thing runs. That is the gap Commonplace fills. Drivers pick up the cart, and buyers get 60 minutes to test it at home before any money changes hands. You never meet the seller, and every item goes through a multi-point inspection before it ships.
That matters more with carts than almost anything, because the expensive failures (a dying battery, a hard-starting engine) only show up when you actually drive the thing. A 60-minute in-home test means you find those problems before you pay, not after. Every purchase is also backed by a 60-day warranty, so a hidden fault is our problem, not yours. You can see the full process on how it works.
Frequently asked questions
Are used gas golf carts cheaper than electric?
Usually about the same up front, but gas is often cheaper to own. A used electric cart can look like a bargain until you learn the battery pack is four years old and needs $900 to $2,000 to replace. Always price the battery into a used electric cart.
How long do golf cart batteries last?
Lead-acid packs last four to six years. Lithium packs last 8 to 10 years. If you are looking at used electric carts, the battery age matters more than the cart’s model year.
Which is better for hills, gas or electric?
Gas. A gas engine makes more torque and climbs steep grades without draining a battery. Stock electric carts can slow badly on hills and lose range fast. If you have a hilly property, buy gas or a high-torque lithium cart.
Do gas golf carts hold their value?
Yes, and more predictably than lead-acid electric carts. Because there is no battery clock ticking, a well-maintained gas cart depreciates slowly and sells fast. Lithium electric carts also hold value well.
Is it safe to buy a used golf cart from a stranger?
It can be, but it is where most bad buys happen, because you cannot properly test range or engine health in a driveway meetup. Buying through a service that inspects the cart, delivers it, and gives you a test window at home removes most of that risk.
The bottom line
Gas or electric comes down to how you drive. Long trips, hills, and towing point to gas. Short quiet loops and low running costs point to electric, as long as the battery is healthy. Whichever way you go, the money is made or lost in the inspection, so buy the cart you can actually test before you pay.
If you are ready to shop, Commonplace lists inspected used golf carts and delivers them with a 60-minute test window, so you find out how the cart really drives before you commit a dollar. And if you have a cart sitting in the garage, listing it is simple: you set it out, a driver handles pickup, and payment lands before the cart leaves your driveway. No strangers, no lowball haggling, no loading it yourself.
See a real one: we interviewed the owner of a 2025 Icon I40L golf cart on the Commonplace Talk Show. Watch the walkthrough and see the listing.
See a real one: we interviewed the owner of a 2020 EZGO Elite Golf Cart on the Commonplace Talk Show. Watch the walkthrough and see the listing.