Used piano buying guide: why a Yamaha U1 or Kawai K-300 is the safe pick, what to pay ($3,000 to $5,000), what to inspect, and the red flags to walk away from.

This used piano buying guide gets to the answer first: for most homes, the used piano to buy is a 48-inch Japanese professional upright like a Yamaha U1 or a Kawai K-300 (or its K-3 predecessor). Plan on roughly $3,000 to $5,000 for a good one from a private seller. Dealer listings with delivery and tuning included run higher, and newer units can top $8,000. Skip spinets, skip "free" pianos with no history, and never pay before a technician or an inspection has seen the pin block and soundboard.
I help people buy and sell big, heavy, awkward things for a living, and pianos are the category where the gap between a great deal and a 500-pound mistake is widest. Two uprights can look identical in photos and be worth $4,000 and $0. So below I cover the models worth buying secondhand, the ones I'd walk away from, what to inspect, what to pay, the red flags in a listing, and how delivery and setup work. If you're on the selling side instead, start with my guide on how to sell a used piano.
The used piano models worth buying are the ones built in big numbers to a consistent standard, with parts and technicians available everywhere. That points to a short list.
Yamaha U1 and U3. The U1 is a 48-inch professional upright, and it's probably the most common serious practice piano on the used market. The U3 is the 52-inch big brother, with longer strings and a bigger, fuller bass. Schools and teachers have used them for decades, which is why so many are around.
Kawai K-300 (and the older K-3 and K-5). The K-300 is a 48-inch upright and the model most often compared head to head with the U1. Kawai's action uses composite parts in places where older pianos use wood, and many players find the touch slightly warmer than a Yamaha. A used K-300 is usually priced a little under a U1 of the same age, which makes it one of the better values in this guide.
Baldwin Hamilton studio. The 45-inch Hamilton is the classic American school piano. Many were built tough for classrooms and church basements. Condition varies a lot because of how hard they were played, but a good one is a solid, honest instrument for a beginner or intermediate player.
Boston (designed by Steinway). Boston uprights and grands sit between the mass-market Japanese brands and Steinway. They're a strong used buy when priced well below new, but a Steinway-adjacent name on the fallboard isn't a reason to pay more than the condition supports.
Yamaha C-series and Kawai GE or GM grands. If you want a grand and have the room, a used Yamaha C1, C2 or C3, or a Kawai baby grand, follows the same logic as the uprights. Consistent build, wide technician familiarity, and a deep resale market.

The used pianos to skip are spinets, unknown-brand uprights with no service history, and any piano that has lived in a damp basement or next to a radiator.
Spinets are the short uprights, usually under 40 inches tall. Many use a drop action, where the keys connect to the hammers through linkages that sit below the keyboard. Technicians generally dislike working on them, and the short strings limit the tone. They look like a bargain. Usually they aren't.
The other big category to skip is the "free piano, you haul it" listing. Some are fine. Many are free because a technician already told the owner the pin block is shot or the piano won't hold a tune. And moving it still costs real money (I go through those costs in how to move or take apart a piano). A free piano that needs $2,000 of work is the most expensive piano in town.
Be careful with gray-market Yamahas too. These are used pianos originally built for the Japanese domestic market and later exported. Yamaha itself has warned that pianos made for Japan's climate may not be seasoned for drier North American homes. Plenty play well. But they should be priced below a U1 that was sold new in the US, and you want a technician to check for loose tuning pins and cracks.
For a used piano like a Yamaha U1, expect to pay about $3,000 to $5,000 in good playing condition, less for older or tired instruments and more from a dealer with service included.
Here's what I've seen in public listings. Dealers have listed refurbished 1980s U1s anywhere from about $3,700 to $6,700, and a 2007 U1 was listed in Brooklyn at $8,050 with delivery, tuning and a warranty included. An eBay U1 sold for $2,995 early this year. One piano dealer's own price guide argues you shouldn't pay over $5,000 for a used U1 in most cases. That matches what I see: the private-sale sweet spot is just under that line.
| Used piano | Size and type | Who it suits | What I'd plan to pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| Yamaha U1 | 48-inch upright | Serious students, adults returning to piano | About $3,000 to $5,000 private; more from a dealer |
| Yamaha U3 | 52-inch upright | Players who want grand-like bass in an upright | Usually above a U1 of the same age |
| Kawai K-300 / K-3 | 48-inch upright | Same buyer as the U1, warmer touch | Often a bit under a comparable U1 |
| Baldwin Hamilton | 45-inch studio | Beginners, families, schools | Well under a U1; condition drives it |
| Gray-market Yamaha | 48 to 52-inch upright | Budget buyers with a technician | Below a US-market U1 |
| Spinet (any brand) | Under 40 inches | Almost nobody | Low, and still often not worth it |
Two things change the number more than the brand does. First, age and use: a 30-year-old U1 that lived in a teaching studio has had a hard life compared with one that sat in a living room. Second, what's included. A dealer price usually bundles delivery, a tuning and a warranty. A private price usually includes nothing, so add moving and a tuning before you compare.
Budget for a tuning after any move. Most technicians charge somewhere around $100 to $200 for a standard tuning, and a piano that hasn't been tuned in years may need a pitch raise first, which costs extra.
The most important thing to inspect on a used piano is whether it holds a tune, and that comes down to the pin block, the soundboard and the strings.
If you can, bring a piano technician. An inspection visit is a small cost against a few thousand dollars. If you can't, here's the checklist I'd run myself:

The biggest red flag in a used piano listing is a seller who can't tell you when it was last tuned. Pianos that are cared for get tuned, and owners remember.
Other listing red flags I watch for:
And never pay a "shipping company" you didn't choose to move a piano you haven't seen. That's the classic piano scam.
Delivering a used piano takes a crew, a piano dolly and a truck with a ramp or lift gate, and it should be followed by a tuning once the piano has settled into the room.
Uprights travel standing up, wrapped in blankets and strapped to the truck wall. Grands come partly apart. The legs, lyre and lid come off and the body rides on its side on a padded board. Stairs are where costs jump, so tell whoever moves it exactly how many steps and turns there are at both ends.
Once it's in place, keep it off outside walls and away from heating vents and sunny windows if you can. Give it a couple of weeks to adjust to your home's humidity, then book the tuning. Tune it right away and you'll often be tuning it again a month later.

This is the part of buying a used piano where I think we make the biggest difference. When you buy a piano on Commonplace, our team picks it up from the seller, inspects it, and delivers it to you. You never meet a stranger, and you pay only after it passes inspection. I've watched buyers in fifth-floor walk-ups get big pieces up the stairs without lifting a finger. You can see how it all fits together on how Commonplace works.
The short version of this used piano buying guide is a simple decision order. Here's how I'd make the call:
Buy the instrument, not the case.
Yes, for most players a used Yamaha U1 is the safest used piano you can buy. It's consistent, easy to service and easy to resell later, which matters if your kid quits in two years.
Age alone isn't the problem. A 40-year-old U1 kept indoors and tuned regularly can play beautifully, while a 15-year-old piano from a damp basement can be finished. Judge the pin block and soundboard, not the date.
Usually the upright. A good 48 to 52-inch upright will outplay a cheap small grand, costs less, and fits more homes. Buy a grand when you have the space and the budget for a quality one.
For anything over about $1,500, I'd say yes. A technician can check the pin block, soundboard and action in under an hour, and that visit costs far less than the mistake it prevents.
Wait about two to three weeks. The piano needs time to settle into your room's temperature and humidity, or the tuning won't last.
If you have a piano to sell, list your piano on Commonplace. Our team handles pickup, so you don't have to find movers or meet buyers. You can also start any listing from our sell page, and if you're torn about selling versus donating, my guide on how to get rid of a piano covers every option.
And if you're shopping, browse used pianos for sale on Commonplace. Every one is inspected before it reaches your door.